| Ryan | Kavounis | Fauquier HS | Methodist Univ. |
| Trevor | McLelland | Loudoun Valley HS | Bridgewater College |
| Ryan Nixon | Defense | Briar Woods HS | US Military Academy West Point |
| Aidan Taplin-Patterson | Midfield | Gonzaga College HS | US Naval Academy |
| Matt Martin | Midfield | Westfields HS | Drexel University |
| Eric Swagerty | Attack | Robinson Secondary School | Robert Morris University |
| Logan Cleary | Attack | Battlefield HS | Cabrini University |
| Caleb McNaull | LPM | Paul VI Catholic HS | Gettysburg College |
| Bjorn Davidson | Midfield | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Williams College |
| Gabe Russell | Goalie | Colgan HS | Shenandoah University |
| Luke Helfgott | Attack | Yorktown HS | Hampden-Sydney College |
| Jackson Palmer | Attack | Paul VI Catholic HS | Colorado Mesa University |
| Wyatt Murphy | LSM/D | St. Andrew's Episcopal School | Christopher Newport University |
| Brandon Young | Defense | John Champe HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Blake Marcey | Midfield | Oakton HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Nick Capannelli | Face Off | Patriot HS | US Air Force Academy |
| Charlie O'Connor | Attack | Paul VI Catholic HS | Duke University |
| Wyatt Marvil | LSM | Thomas Jefferson HS for Science and Technology | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| | | |
2019 Team | | | |
| Alex Brendes | Attack | Dominion High School | Christopher Newport University |
| Brian Collins | Midfield | Gonzaga College HS | Lafayette College |
| Tony Diallo | Defense | St. Andrew's Episcopal School | University of Maryland Baltimore County |
| JT Dolan | Midfield | Yorktown HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Ryan Duncan | Attack | Loudoun County HS | Lafayette College |
| Riley Fitzsimmons | Goalie | Bishop Denis J. O'Connell HS | Fairfield University |
| Kevin Gaston | Face Off | Bishop Denis J. O'Connell HS | Limestone College |
| Henry Holliday | Midfield | St. Alban's School | Washington & Lee University |
| Garrett Kurtz | Attack | Landon School | Tufts University |
| Noah Lee | Midfield | St. Andrew's Episcopal School | Lynchburg College |
| Kevin McDaid | Attack | Oakton HS | Rutgers University |
| Zach Myers | Defense | Freedom HS | Marquette University |
| Ethan Opdahl | Defense | St. Andrew's Episcopal School | Bucknell University |
| Jack Posey | Defense | Freedom HS | Penn State University |
| Jack Praver | Defense | Cape Henry Collegiate | Furman University |
| Patton Robertson | Midfield | IMG Academy | Lafayette College |
| Dalton Young | Attack | John Champe HS | University of Richmond |
| Gabe Zimmerman | Midfield | Georgetown Preparatory School | Dickinson College |
| Ryan Young | Defense | Briar Woods HS | Christopher Newport |
| Danny McMinn | Attack | Briar Woods HS | Christopher Newport |
| Jim Davis | Midfielder | Stone Bridge HS | Bridgewater |
| Quinn McCann | SSD Mid | Loudown Valley | Bridgewater |
| Riley Green | Goalie | Loudoun Valley | Mary Washington |
| Robby Adams | Midfielder | Loudoun Valley | Christopher Newport |
| | | |
2018 Team | | | |
| Michael Asuncion | Midfield | St. Albans School | Kenyon College |
| Andrew Bolin | Midfield | McCallie School | Sewanee University |
| Grant Dearden | Defense/LPM | Paul VI Catholic HS | Penn State University |
| Brandon Fisher | Midfield | Paul VI Catholic HS | Ohio State University |
| Michael Hraba | Goalie | State College Area HS | Lynchburg College |
| Nate Jensen | Attack | Briar Woods HS | Lynchburg College |
| Kyle Kivinski | Attack | Dominion HS | University of Delaware |
| Rainier Lee | Midfield | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Providence College |
| Silas Newsome | Defense/LPM | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Brown University |
| Nick Nies | Midfield | Freedom HS | Lenoir-Rhyne University |
| Drew Pirko | Defense/LPM | Freedom HS | University of Hartford |
| Blake Rodgers | Defense/LPM | Herndon HS | Johns Hopkins University |
| Mason Romm | Midfield | Thomas Wootton HS | Bucknell University |
| Nick Rowlett | Face Off | Robinson Secondary School | University of Michigan |
| Reid Scarborough | Midfield | Freedom HS | Virginia Military Institute |
| Jack Siegel | Goalie | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Amherst College |
| Carter Tate | Attack | St. Albans School | Amherst College |
| Jack Wood | Midfield | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Trinity College |
| | | |
2017 Team | | | |
| Michael Abizaid | Face Off | Landon School | Furman University |
| Grant Ammann | Defense/LPM | Woodgrove HS | High Point University |
| Nate Buller | Attack | Landon School | Duke University |
| Miles Collins | Midfield | McLean HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Andrew Fowler | Defense/LPM | Landon School | Cornell University |
| Brian Geffroy | Midfield | St. Albans School | Haverford College |
| Matt Harris | Attack | Briar Woods HS | Colgate University |
| Danny Kielbasa | Attack | Paul VI Catholic HS | US Military Academy at West Point |
| Kadin Kightlinger | Midfield | Bishop Denis J. O'Connell HS | Gettysburg College |
| Jackson Miller | Attack | W. T. Woodson HS | Palm Beach Atlantic University |
| Harrison Osborne | Midfield | The Potomac School | Amherst College |
| Joseph Otero | Defense | Robinson Secondary School | Virginia Military Institute |
| Kevin Petrillo | Midfield | Westfield HS | Georgetown University |
| Ryan Pride | Midfield | Landon School | University of Virginia |
| Roman Puglise | Midfield | Paul VI Catholic HS | University of Maryland |
| Jack Starr | Goalie | St. Albans School | Yale University |
| Sam Swagerty | Midfield/Attack | Robinson Secondary School | Christopher Newport University |
| | | |
2016 Team | | | |
| Adam Baker | Goalie | Paul VI Catholic HS | Mount St. Mary's University |
| Griffin Brown | Midfield | Landon School | Colgate University |
| Jae Hoon Choi | Defense | Langley HS | Elizabethtown College |
| Johnny Daniel | Attack | Robinson Secondary School | Virginia Military Institute |
| Michael Foster | Midfield | Saint John Paul the Great Catholic HS | Jacksonville University |
| Josh Grafton | Defense | Woodgrove HS | Lynchburg College |
| Conor James | LPM | Woodgrove HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Palmer Lloyd | F/O Midfield | James Madison HS | Rutgers University |
| John Markovs | Midfield | Bullis School | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Chris McLallen | Attack | James Madison HS | High Point University |
| Colin Meehan | Midfield | Chantilly HS | US Naval Academy |
| Brian Menendez | Midfield | Landon School | Salisbury University |
| Jake Pehlke | Defense | Stone Bridge HS | Monmouth University |
| Jeff Pisani | Defense/LPM | Paul VI Catholic HS | Lynchburg College |
| Ryan Reynolds | Goalie | Woodgrove HS | Elizabethtown College |
| John Schmank | Defense | Paul VI Catholic HS | Virginia Military Institute |
| Conor Shears | Defense | Yorktown HS | Bucknell University |
| CJ Stowell | Attack | Paul VI Catholic HS | Saint Joseph's University |
| | | |
2015 Team | | | |
| Tim Aldinger | Defense/LPM | Yorktown HS | Roanoke College |
| Luke Brugel | Face Off | Paul VI Catholic HS | University of Virginia |
| Shane Brummond | Midfield | Oakton HS | Lynn University |
| Jude Buckholz | Defense/LPM | Robinson Secondary School | Salisbury University |
| Chris Delente | Midfield | Saint John's Catholic Prep | New Jersey Institute of Technology |
| Spud Dunn | Midfield | Landon School | Trinity College |
| Thomas Evans | Defense | Landon School | US Naval Academy |
| Liam Frerichs | Goalie | Boys' Latin School of Maryland | US Military Academy at West Point |
| Andrew Garstka | Midfield | Paul VI Catholic HS | Gettysburg College |
| Patrick Gyenis | Defense | Paul VI Catholic HS | University of Maryland |
| Chapman Jasien | Attack | Robinson Secondary School | US Naval Academy |
| Ryan Lamb | Midfield | Paul VI Catholic HS | University of Virginia |
| Robbie McLallen | Midfield | James Madison HS | Haverford College |
| Teddy Myers | Attack/Midfield | Gonzaga College HS | Furman University |
| Bryce Nalls | Defense | South County HS | Quinnipiac University |
| Jake Newsome | Attack | Washington-Lee HS | Brown University |
| Ryan O'Connor | Midfield | Paul VI Catholic HS | University of North Carolina |
| Kyle Petrillo | Defense | Westfield HS | Amherst College |
| Kevin Quigley | Midfield | South County HS | Bryant University |
| Jack Rowlett | Defense | Robinson Secondary School | University of North Carolina |
| Ty Wedekind | Goalie | Our Lady of Good Counsel HS | Rollins College |
| Chris White | Attack | Robinson Secondary School | University of Mary Washington |
| David Williamson | Midfield | Paul VI Catholic HS | Furman University |
| Drew Wiseman | Attack/Midfield | St. Stephan's & St. Agnes School | Colorado College |
| Jarett Witzal | Face Off | Landon School | Bucknell University |
| | | |
2014 Team | | | |
| Chris Albright | Midfield | James Madison HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Nate Archer | Attack | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Cornell University |
| Zac Buller | Attack | Landon School | Jacksonville University |
| Jack Frail | Midfield | South Lakes HS | Hampden-Sydney College |
| Cory Harris | Midfield | Oakton HS | University of Virginia |
| Kyle Harwood | Midfield | Yorktown HS | Robert Morris University |
| Kevin Haverman | Face Off | The Potomac School | Washington & Lee University |
| Zach Jecklin | Attack | Collegiate School | Hampden-Sydney College |
| Brandon Johnson | Midfield | Landon School | University of Virginia |
| Graham Lian | LPM | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Colby College |
| Alex Mandel | Midfield | St. Albans School | Swathmore College |
| JT Meyer | Attack | Langley HS | US Naval Academy |
| Andrew Mitchell | Defense | Landon School | US Military Academy at West Point |
| Robby Moore | Defense | Washington-Lee HS | Roanoke College |
| Nico Pollack | Attack | Yorktown HS | Tufts University |
| Connor Sweeney | Face Off | The Potomac School | Gettysburg College |
| Jones Veith | Attack | St. Stephen's & St. Agnes School | Washington & Lee University |
| Ryan Wade | Attack | Norfolk Academy | US Naval Academy |
| Hunter Yates | Defense | Langley HS | Washington & Lee University |
| | | |
2013 Team | | | |
| Matt Arndt | Midfield | James Madison HS | Bridgewater College |
| Jacob Dansey | Defense | Chantilly HS | Boston University |
| Brad Dotson | Defense | Langley HS | Bucknell University |
| Matt Hayden | Goalie | James Madison HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Bill Leslie | Attack | Chantilly HS | Frostburg State University |
| Connor Murphy | Attack | Paul VI Catholic HS | Ritgers University |
| Mikey Ripa | Attack | Bishop Denis J. O'Connell HS | Mount St. Mary's University |
| Kyle Rowe | Face Off | James Madison HS | Stony Brook University |
| Luke Salzar | Midfield | Langley HS | University of Delaware |
| Mikey Woo | Midfield | St. Albans School | Sewanee University |
| | | |
2012 Team | | | |
| Alex Barber | Attack | Robinson Secondary School | Christopher Newport University |
| Donald Devine | LPM | Loudon Valley HS | Robert Morris University |
| Matt Dunwoody | Defense | Oakton HS | University of Tampa |
| Dan Gullucci | Midfield | Langley HS | Randolp-Macon College |
| Brady George | Defense | Robinson Secondary School | University of Delaware |
| Spencer Gorham | Face Off | Langley HS | Union College |
| Hunter Guttendorf | Attack | W. T. Woodson HS | Hampden-Sydney College |
| Andrew Lohmann | LPM | Oakton HS | Rensselaer Polytchnic Institute |
| Connor McGillicuddy | Midfield | Justice HS | Mars Hill College |
| Sean Ohlhaver | Midfield | Bishop Denis J. O'Connell HS | Shenandoah University |
| ChristopherPaddock | Attack | Avon Old Farms | Limestone College |
| Denis Radcliffe | Midfield | Woodgrove HS | Stevenson University |
| Clay Rivers | Midfield | Langley HS | Mercer University |
| Alex Rock | Defense | Gonzaga College HS | High Point University |
| Alex Vicas | Goalie | St. Alabans School | Georgetown University |
| Alec Villafina | Face Off | Annandale HS | Mount Olive College |
| Connor Wade | Goalie | W. T. Woodson HS | US Naval Academy |
| | | |
2011 Team | | | |
| Nico Burns | Midfield | Washington-Lee HS | Marymount University |
| Michael Crowe | Attack | Yorktown HS | Stevenson University |
| Michael Mabry | Defense | Broad Run HS | Christopher Newport University |
| Ryan Madigan | Attack | Broad Run HS | Robert Morris University |
| Nathan Miller | Midfield | Annandale HS | US Military Academy at West Point |
| | | |
2010 Team | | | |
| Chris Daddio | Face Off | Loudon Valley HS | Syracuse University |
| Thomas Robinson | Defense | Langley HS | Loyola University Maryland |
| Andrew Senft | Attack | Robert E. Lee HS | Ferrum College |
| Garrett Swankowski | Defense | Loudon Valley HS | University Of Virginia |
| Derek Zook | Defense | Loudon Valley HS | Loyola University Maryland |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
